WordPress at a Crossroads: Community Fractures and Uncertain Futures

By now, we’ve covered WordPress’s biggest problems — security issues, plugin bloat, and admin frustrations. But there’s one more layer to consider:

The WordPress ecosystem itself is becoming unstable.

And we’re not talking about technical glitches — we’re talking about the people behind the platform, and the growing tension within the community that powers it.

A Community Divided

WordPress was born as an open-source project for blogging, built and maintained by a passionate community of developers, contributors, and volunteers.

But as the platform grew, so did commercial interests — especially after the rise of Automattic, the company founded by WordPress co-creator Matt Mullenweg. Automattic runs WordPress.com and contributes heavily to the development of WordPress.org (the open-source version).

This creates tension:

• Who controls the future of WordPress?
• Are decisions made for the community, or for the corporate backers?
• Are contributors truly being heard?

The WP Engine Conflict

In late 2024 and into early 2025, a public clash between Automattic (the company behind WordPress.com) and WP Engine (a major WordPress hosting provider) shook the WordPress ecosystem.

What happened:

• Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg publicly accused WP Engine of being a “cancer” to the WordPress project and misleading users by using the “WP” brand name.
• He demanded that WP Engine either pay an 8% revenue royalty or contribute equivalent development resources to the WordPress open-source project (The Verge).
• WP Engine refused, leading to a broader legal and platform access conflict.

Key fallout:

• Automattic revoked WP Engine’s access to WordPress.org tools, including the plugin and theme repositories, which affected thousands of WP Engine-hosted customers (TechCrunch follow-up).
• A court eventually ruled against Automattic and ordered that access be restored.
• In the aftermath, Yoast’s former CEO called for a federated governance model — urging the WordPress community to rethink how decisions are made and who has control.

Why it matters:

• It revealed deep friction between open-source contributors and corporate influence.
• It created real-world uncertainty for hosts, developers, and businesses that depend on the WordPress infrastructure.
• It raised fundamental questions: Who owns WordPress? Who controls its future? And what happens when big players disagree?

This wasn’t just a business dispute. It was a wake-up call for anyone depending on WordPress to run their site. For a CMS that already struggles with complexity, these community divisions make things worse — not better.

Infinitus: Built Without the Baggage

Infinitus CMS isn’t tied to a shifting develoment community or corporate politics. It’s built, hosted, and maintained by our team at Ingenious — and only us.

That means:

• A clear roadmap based on client needs, not ecosystem drama
• One clear path forward, without fragmentation or detours.
• A platform that evolves deliberately and responsibly

In other words: we’re accountable to you, not a fractured developer community.

Wrapping Up: The Smarter Alternative

Over this five-part series, we’ve shown how WordPress:

• Wasn’t built to be a modern CMS
• Relies too heavily on plugins
• Creates friction in everyday admin use
• Exposes your site to serious security risks
• And now, faces real questions about its future

Infinitus CMS is our answer to all of that.

If you’re ready for a faster, cleaner, more stable platform — designed for real business needs — we’d love to show you what’s possible.

Check out InfinitusCMS.com or contact us to learn more.